NEWS. CULTURE. COMMON SENSE.

Obama Investigation Found Ilhan Omar Likely Committed Immigration Fraud, But She Still Wasn’t Charged

Federal prosecutors in Minnesota during President Trump’s first term investigated Representative Ilhan Omar for possible immigration fraud related to allegations that she married her brother and misstated details on citizenship paperwork, concluding she “had likely taken part in immigration fraud,” according to people familiar with the probe.

The inquiry was closed without charges because the statute of limitations had expired, the Star Tribune reported, citing three individuals familiar with the investigation conducted while Erica MacDonald served as U.S. Attorney for Minnesota.

A separate 2016 FBI probe examined the 2009 marriage and found “some evidence” of fraud but was shut down for the same reason: the five-year window had closed in 2014.

In 2019, a political appointee in the first Trump administration directed Homeland Security Investigations to review Omar’s immigration records; the agency ultimately found insufficient evidence and abandoned a full investigation.

The current inquiry, which included an October 12 search of Omar’s Washington, D.C., home, is being handled by D.C. prosecutors and has bypassed the Minnesota U.S. Attorney’s Office where earlier probes ended.

Legal expert Alan Dershowitz stated, “I think this is the beginning of a much deeper search, which will end very, very likely in her denaturalization and deportation,” noting that statutes of limitations applicable to criminal cases do not apply in denaturalization proceedings.

He added that the matter “could be a continuing crime if she has continued to say things like her birth date, which were part of a fraud.”

Minnesota Republican Representative Tom Emmer said Omar “is a dishonest, anti-American individual who has lied about her age for years.”

Emmer explained that naturalization with a parent is available only to those under 18 at the time of the parent’s naturalization, and that Omar’s documents allegedly listed a birth year that placed her under that threshold when she was in fact older.

“What I’m saying is the birth date is an administrative procedure, and once it’s established that she was over the age of 18 when she claimed to be a minor, she’s no longer a citizen of the United States,” Emmer said.

“And when she’s no longer a citizen, she’s not entitled to serve in Congress.”

The current investigation also examines Omar’s financial disclosures in addition to the marriage and citizenship questions.

A D.C. grand jury is already hearing evidence, and U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro has confirmed that financial matters form part of the case.

Earlier reviews during the Obama years and the first Trump term reached the same core conclusion of likely fraud but were constrained by time limits or insufficient evidence standards at the time.

Omar has previously revised financial disclosures after initial filings, attributing discrepancies to accounting errors.

The October search warrant listed potential charges including conspiracy, immigration fraud, and false statements, according to a person familiar with the document.

Judge James Boasberg is scheduled to hear media efforts to unseal related records.

The case continues to center on whether Omar or her late father intentionally misstated her birth date on immigration paperwork so she could derive citizenship as a minor.

ANALYZING AMERICA

Join the Conversation

0 comments

Share your perspective and reply to other readers.

Free account required. You will stay on this page.
Be the first to comment.