NEWS. CULTURE. COMMON SENSE.

Mamdani ENDS 150-Year-Old NYC Tradition

Democrat New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed a law Thursday that will end horse-drawn carriage rides by June 1, 2028. The measure places an expiration date on a Central Park tradition that President Donald Trump argued the city should keep.

Mamdani signed Romanch’s Law at City Hall alongside City Council Speaker Julie Menin and former Mayor Bill de Blasio, who had pushed for a ban while in office. The law ends the issuance of new carriage licenses and gives existing operators until June 2028 to stop offering rides. The City Council approved the measure 40–7 on October 22.

“For 150 years, horse-drawn carriages have been a fixture of Central Park. Today, we are bringing that chapter to a close,” Mamdani said. “This industry will come to an end, and we have a responsibility to the workers whose livelihoods depend on it. We will work alongside them to ensure they have the financial support and career opportunities they need to build their next chapter.”

The city plans to buy back medallions from carriage owners and offer stipends to drivers and stable hands who attend job training. City Hall estimates about 200 people make their living in the industry and expects to release a full plan by April 2027 after consulting workers and their union.

Trump criticized the ban in two Truth Social posts hours before the council vote. He argued that the city was ending a tradition more than a century old largely because of one tragic accident and pointed to car crashes around Central Park, asking why those had not led the city to bar cars from the park.

“So sad to see the beloved Central Park Horse-drawn Carriage Industry ending after over a Century, based largely on one tragic accident,” Trump wrote. “When there is a car accident in the area, of which there are many, they don’t stop cars from entering the Park. So why would they stop the Carriages? It was a Great Tradition. Another piece of History that’s gone. It will be missed!”

In a separate post, Trump called the rides “a quintessential New York experience” and said they were going away “for political reasons.”

Minutes after Mamdani signed the law, the Transport Workers Union filed a federal lawsuit in Manhattan seeking to block it. Union President John Samuelsen said some owners paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for city-issued medallions and argued that the law takes them away without guaranteeing compensation.

The union also challenged a provision that bars owners from selling their horses to carriage operators elsewhere, including in states where the rides are legal. The law bars sending the horses to slaughter. City officials say sanctuaries and rescue groups are prepared to take in horses as they retire.

The law is named for Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist from India who died on June 17 after a horse bolted in Central Park. His family had arrived in New York three days earlier. Relatives said Mahajan fell while trying to catch his mother, who was also thrown from the carriage and survived. The city medical examiner ruled his death accidental and listed blunt force trauma as the cause.

The phase-out timeline gives operators roughly 18 months after the signing. Existing licenses remain valid until the 2028 cutoff.

Compensation details for medallion buybacks and worker stipends have not yet been finalized. The April 2027 plan date is intended to allow consultation with affected workers.

The lawsuit seeks to preserve the industry and protect owners’ investments in medallions. It also contests restrictions on horse sales.

Trump’s posts framed the decision as an unnecessary loss of a longstanding attraction. He contrasted the response to the carriage incident with the continued presence of automobiles in the park.

The ban’s supporters cite animal welfare and public safety concerns stemming from the fatal accident. Opponents emphasize the economic impact on workers and the cultural role of the carriages.

Further court proceedings on the union’s challenge will determine whether the law takes full effect as written. Implementation steps continue in parallel.

ANALYZING AMERICA

Join the Conversation

0 comments

Share your perspective and reply to other readers.

Free account required. You will stay on this page.
Be the first to comment.